Reid Chaney was declared the winner against Michael Songer after capturing 1,558 of the 2,994 votes cast, while Songer fell short with 1,366 votes.
"We're so excited," Chaney said. "We started out being the underdog with just a small network of friends, and we really had to gain support from people."
When Board of Elections Chairman Jeremy Tuchmayer announced the election results, Chaney first jumped up and embraced his campaign staff before extending a handshake to his opponent.
Chaney gave credit for his victory to his staff and campaign workers who helped him in the race. "Jon Kanipe was the best campaign manager ever," Chaney said. "Everyone was a big help."
While the celebratory hugs and congratulations were passed around the Chaney camp, there was a solemn atmosphere among Songer's supporters.
"I'm really disappointed," Songer said. "I think we had a lot of great ideas, and it's unfortunate that they won't be implemented."
Songer said he is not sure if he will have a future with CAA. "We'll have to see what happens," Songer said. "I'm not prepared to make that decision tonight."
Songer believes his unpopular platform proposal of taking away Carolina Fever's allotted basketball seating bloc was one of the reasons for his loss. "I clearly think our stance on Fever hurt us a lot," Songer said. "In the end, there was just one special interest group out there that was just too vocal to overcome."
The first election held two weeks ago originally called for a runoff election, but Chaney was then declared the winner after the Board of Elections invalidated 27 write-in votes.