Mouse politely tells him The Cave doesn't have a spot for him but assures the artist he will pass on his demo to Hideaway Restaurant & Bar, a club where he thinks the music will go over better.
"We all work together," Mouse says after he hangs up the phone. "Go (Rehearsal Inc.) and Local 506 will send me bands, and I'll send them stuff. That's what's nice about booking in this town. I've got some really good acts down here because of that."
The phone rings again. The Yellow Stars, a new pop act from Durham, is on the other end wanting a show.
Mouse looks in his book, a worn black binder with calendars, contact information and his own personal reviews of every CD the club has been sent since March 2000.
"What kind of crowd can you draw?" he asks the band. "Do you guys like to play late? You guys have enough music for two sets?"
In the end, the Yellow Stars get a spot on the calendar. "If they're local, they'll get a show," Mouse says.
Sounds Local
Commitment to local music seems to be the norm at clubs in Chapel Hill. Most venues make an effort to include as much local music as possible while still bringing in enough better-known acts to keep the doors open. Even the Cat's Cradle, the club in town, has its Sunday Showcase, a monthly show for eight lesser-known local acts.
The Cradle's little sister, Go, tries to showcase local acts whenever it can, said Mike Triplett, who books shows at the Brewer Lane club.
"We're here to support independent and local artists," he said. "I'm a firm believer of mixing local bands with out-of-town touring bands. It opens the doors for local bands to start touring."
It also allows some local acts to play for larger audiences than would otherwise come to their shows.
Triplett said he also tries to book shows of two or three local acts that individually would not have a large draw but together can bring out more people.
To get the day's news and headlines in your inbox each morning, sign up for our email newsletters.
But even if clubs in town are willing to support a broad range of local music, that doesn't necessarily mean it's easy for local artists to get shows, especially if they're just starting out.
Josh Maher, singer and guitarist for Brazilia, a local indie-punk outfit that's been around for about two years, said his band actually played shows in Washington, D.C., and Pennsylvania before it could get a show locally.
"It was easier to book out of town than in Chapel Hill," he said. "Even though it's a small town, it's one of those major market places."
The number of touring national acts and established local bands playing Chapel Hill's stages makes it hard for acts just starting out to get their foot in the door, he said.
"Coming to a club as a band from out of town almost makes you seem more professional," Maher said, laughing at the irony.
But, he added, after playing in town for a while, booking became progressively easier with each show.
Now, Maher said, the band can focus more time on booking tours.
Once they reach the nationally and internationally touring level, some local bands opt for booking agents.
Jim Romeo, who runs the Carrboro-based Ground Control booking agency, started out booking tours for some now-defunct local heavyweights like the Archers of Loaf. He now handles booking for many bands on Durham's Merge Records, as well as acts like Guided by Voices.
"A lot of bands don't really have the time to book tours; they want someone else to do it who has experience," he said.
Romeo handles the logistics of booking a tour for his clients -- itineraries, drive times and of course the shows.
Although most of the bands Ground Control works for have substantial national followings, Romeo's work directly affects young bands like Brazilia trying to get shows in Chapel Hill.
Triplett said those national touring acts are what keep people coming to Go.
"I deal a lot with the agents that have rosters of national acts. Those come first," he said. "I'm trying to cater mostly to the agents. Those are the ones that do really well for us. Then I try to put the local bands on those shows to help them out."
Making It Happen
So how do local bands get that first show opening up for a bigger act?
"You have to be persistent," Triplett said. "You do need to call people back."
Mouse had similar advice.
"If you don't call me I'm not going to call you," he said.
Both Triplett and Mouse said they listen to all the demos bands send them. But when you get 20 or 30 packages in the mail each week, it's easy to get backed up, Triplett said.
"Sometimes it takes me three months to get back to someone about the package they sent me," he said.
There are some things bands can do to speed the process up, the most important being to send their music on CD instead of cassette. Most clubs don't have tape players anymore, Triplett said, so it takes even longer to listen to a tape demo.
Another thing is to keep whatever supplemental information accompanies the music to a minimum.
"I don't read everything because it's all propaganda," Mouse said, referring to press kits and reviews that many bands send along with their music.
Triplett also said he tended to skip lengthy press packages. "The thing I hate the most is when I get packages of garbage," he said. "It's just people wasting their money. Tour dates, reviews from places I've never heard of -- I don't care how big their press kit is. I don't care how Dan met Ben."
Triplett and Mouse said the best thing to send along with music was a one-page biography with contact information.
But even then, the most important thing is still the music.
Romeo said the same is true for bands that want to use booking agents, with all their connections and clout. "A lot of bands come to me and say, `We don't have a record out, but we want to tour.' And I really just can't do anything for them."
Mouse said he really doesn't care if a band has an agent, a great press kit or even a good photo.
He looked down at the CDs lying in front of him on the bar.
"That is the indicator of whether you're going to play here or not."
The Arts & Entertainment Editor can be reached at artsdesk@unc.edu.