But that's exactly what happened when he took off down the field after kicking the game-winning field goal as time expired in Saturday's game.
"I think I thought of it earlier in the year when we were watching tape against Duke," Orner said. "I saw the helmet, I said, 'Man, that would be kind of cool if I kick the game winner and I ran out through the helmet.'"
Players tried to mob him sooner, but they couldn't catch him.
"I tried to catch Orner, but he was too fast," said UNC tight end Bobby Blizzard.
But Orner had a premonition that he would play a part in winning a big game at the last minute.
"I've had dreams the whole year that sooner or later I'd kick a game winner," he said. "I also had dreams that I was going to miss an extra point. Both of them came true. I'm glad the second came true after the first."
So were the Tar Heels.
"It's just huge relief, joy," said offensive guard Jeb Terry. "The season has been so hard for us, especially the seniors, a lot of trying times. You can't find a better way to end the season, beating Duke, playing like that."
Orner missed an extra point attempt after UNC's third touchdown, putting the Tar Heels up 20-14.