The Daily Tar Heel
Printing news. Raising hell. Since 1893.
Monday, Nov. 25, 2024 Newsletters Latest print issue

We keep you informed.

Help us keep going. Donate Today.
The Daily Tar Heel

Did you know disagreements can be artful? Neither did we.

Frank Bruni and Margaret Spellings responded to questions during "The Art of Disagreement," hosted by the Institute of Politics in Graham Memorial Lounge on Tuesday night. 

Frank Bruni and Margaret Spellings responded to questions during "The Art of Disagreement," hosted by the Institute of Politics in Graham Memorial Lounge on Tuesday night. 

The Art of Disagreement, a talk hosted by the UNC Institute of Politics Tuesday, focused on how to promote thoughtful debate in the midst of a politically divided era.

The two keynote speakers were Frank Bruni, a UNC-Chapel Hill graduate and Pulitzer prize-winning New York Times columnist, and UNC-system President Margaret Spellings.  

The IOP organized the event as a response to the growing political polarization on college campuses. Tanner Glenn, founder and executive director of the IOP who helped organize the event, said one of the group’s objectives was to engage and inspire the next generation of public servants.

"Both Frank and President Spellings have a lot to contribute to the conversation about how we can respectfully disagree but still find common ground on issues that we care about," Glenn said.

The speakers also discussed the role of social media in growing polarization. Bruni and Spellings both discussed Twitter, and how the anonymity of the internet can cause people to use harsher language than they would in real life. People may also feel ostracized because their beliefs do not perfectly align within the categories of the Republican and Democratic parties. 

Bruni said there are many people in the country who are politically homeless. 

“I think we still have shared values, we just define this different ways at times," he said. "I think most Americans would tell you they believe in equal opportunity.”

Bruni mentioned how the journalism atmosphere is fueling a lack of discussion between people of different opinions. 

“We notice that opinion writing is very extreme,” Bruni said. “It is not an accident that is what is being clicked on.”

Spellings and Bruni both said while at a university, people tend to self-segregate into groups where their beliefs are affirmed by their peers. 

“I think some of the differences are because there are fewer opportunities to build relationships with one another,” Spellings said. “What is really foundational is, what do we agree about? We need to find ways to keep people working together around shared values.”

The event provided an opportunity for attendees to anonymously submit questions.

“We have to recognize what people’s backgrounds are,” Bruni said in response to a question asking how to deal with those who may not respect other identities or beliefs. “I think that’s going to be more powerful.”

The two speakers were chosen because of their varying ideological stances. Spellings served as education secretary under the George W. Bush administration and worked to pass the No Child Left Behind legislation. 

“I think that Spellings has taken some kind of hypocritical stances on free speech,” said Maya Little, a UNC graduate student who attended the event.

Little mentioned both the appointment of an undercover police officer at the Silent Sam sit-in and the passing of a new free speech policy by the UNC Board of Governors as examples of free speech issues on campus.

“These are issues that I feel that she hasn’t answered to at all,” Little said.

@ronnieacorrea

state@dailytarheel.com

To get the day's news and headlines in your inbox each morning, sign up for our email newsletters.