Editor's note: This article is satire.
The "Who Would Win" book series is a collection that pits two animals against each other and evaluates who would win. Here are my own, with a modern twist.
Meredith Grey vs. Optimus Prime
Meredith Grey, the main character of "Grey’s Anatomy," is one of the most popular TV characters of all time. Throughout the series she has suffered losses and experienced a variety of traumatic events including (but not limited to) a hospital shooting, a plane crash, a bombing and almost drowning. It would make sense then, that you would think she would survive an encounter with Optimus Prime. Unfortunately for Meredith, Optimus Prime is a literal machine. He would absolutely pulverize her. If Optimus was in his truck form he would be able to hit her, not unlike her own husband, Derek Shepherd, who was hit by a truck. Or, if Optimus Prime was in his big robot form, he would still destroy Meredith. A quick search online reveals that Optimus is a whopping 28 feet tall, and Meredith Grey would stand no chance. I think it would take a simple swing from this big robot and Meredith Grey would perish. True brute power.
Optimus Prime: 1 Meredith Grey: 0
Immanuel Kant vs. the SeaWorld Orca that killed its trainer
Like other naive freshmen college students, I had the great displeasure of becoming friends with philosophy majors my first year at UNC. During that time I was reluctantly exposed to their passion for men who thought long and hard about things. One of these thinkers was Immanuel Kant, a German philosopher. From what I remember, Kant thought a lot about how humans reason and said that our experiences shape the way we understand things (I think, I don’t really care anymore).
The SeaWorld orca Tilikum became famous for being involved in several fatal attacks. The documentary "Blackfish" explored the psychological effects of sustained captivity on whales, one of which was increased aggression.
Kant and Tilikum is a toss up. Perhaps Tilikum would feel pity for a man whose entire life is devoted to sitting and thinking about things that don’t matter and nobody cares about. Kant himself, however, would be the first to know that this whale would not be able to reason through such things. Tilikum is not a human. He is not capable of connecting reason to morality and feeling pity. For this reason, I will hand this battle to Tilikum. I can’t imagine Kant got many workouts in on account of how much time he spent pondering. Like the age-old saying goes, “one whale vs. a philosopher makes for a crazy battle, but the whale wins big.”