The Daily Tar Heel
Printing news. Raising hell. Since 1893.
Sunday, Dec. 22, 2024 Newsletters Latest print issue

We keep you informed.

Help us keep going. Donate Today.
The Daily Tar Heel

Column: Don't let right-wing college campus debaters rile you up

charlie-kirk-wire
Charlie Kirk speaks during Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump’s rally at Gas South Arena in Duluth on Wednesday, Oct. 23, 2024. Photo by Arvin Temkar / AJC via Tribune Content Agency.

If I had to play Kiss, Marry, Kill with Ben Shapiro, Steven Crowder and Charlie Kirk, I’d choose to stay unborn. But even then, these wannabe men would probably insist life begins at nonbeing, and I’d be forced to see the situation through.

Shapiro’s insistence that “facts don’t care about your feelings” paints him as smug and sententious. Crowder’s tendency to mock vulnerable communities under the guise of “free speech” doesn’t make him much better, and when Kirk said he’d make his hypothetical 10-year-old daughter carry a pregnancy to term if she were raped, I realized he and I wouldn’t get along too well.

Everyone’s entitled to their opinions, I guess, but it frustrates me when people like this act as though they have the moral authority to set up on college campuses and pontificate their offensive views.

A couple weeks ago, Kirk and failed politician Vivek Ramaswamy made an appearance at UNC as part of their “You’re Being Brainwashed Tour,” organized by Turning Point USA, a group Kirk founded. The event included a Q&A section, reminiscent of Crowder’s "(I’m a useless member of society), change my mind” tabling stunts, where provocative ideas were hotly pitched with little room for nuanced discussion.

To right-wing provocateurs, college campuses are the ideal battleground. Students are often in the early stages of political understanding, eager to defend their views and passionate about the causes they support, making them particularly vulnerable to the bait of political instigators. And ultimately, liberals and leftists on these college campuses hand Kirk and his goons exactly what they’re after.

When people get angry, it plays right into their hands — through viral videos captioned with “screaming liberal owned,” they attract more people to their side by appearing composed and intelligent, while the person they provoke ends up looking foolish. This manipulative strategy not only boosts credibility among supporters but also amplifies divisions, reinforcing a political clash that feels impossible to bridge.

While it feels as though few people today maintain an open mind, individuals like Shapiro or Kirk only intensify the divides within our already polarized society. It’s not that stubborn leftists don’t contribute to the right’s frustration — they do — but at least defending women’s rights and advocating for an opportunity economy doesn’t require sacrificing empathy or common sense.

And they know people feel this way. When Crowder sets up his “Change My Mind” table or Shapiro’s Daily Wire clips go viral with jabs at liberals, it’s less about fostering dialogue and more about stoking reactions. They know that their tactics will rile people up. That’s part of the point.

This isn't just about ideological battles; in fact, these arguments benefit their cause. Kirk’s TPUSA isn’t just some grassroots student movement. It’s funded by wealthy interests who thrive on division and inequality.

Billionaire donors like the Koch brothers, Robert Mercer and members of the DeVos family, along with other corporate giants, fund Kirk’s brainchild to push a narrative that pits everyday people against each other. It’s not about advocating for free speech or standing up for “traditional values” — they’re advancing a political agenda where the ultra-wealthy remain at the top while everyone else is left fighting each other over scraps.

Our biggest threat isn’t the person with a different opinion, but the corporate elites who keep us down. They don’t care about your gender, race or political beliefs, so long as you pour more energy into fighting over those divisions than uniting to challenge them. The class war is real, and the elites want to manipulate students into propagating their agenda.

You won’t make Ben Shapiro less self-righteous in his arguments. Charlie Kirk doesn’t care that his platform is built on exploiting fear and division for profit. And you won’t change Steven Crowder’s mind. By opposing these contentious pundits, we platform them exactly how they want. Don't waste your time trying.

@dthopinion | opinion@dailytarheel.com

To get the day's news and headlines in your inbox each morning, sign up for our email newsletters.