But now, UNC looks different.
Four days before the 2024 season, longtime head coach Anson Dorrance retired after 45 seasons, leaving Nahas to lead one of the most successful programs in collegiate athletics. But Dorrance also left him with a brand new team.
Four first-years, five transfers and two newcomers.
Nahas was left a team that needed to learn to play with one another without the person that made North Carolina women's soccer what it is: Dorrance.
Still, the Tar Heels only suffered four regular season losses — all against ranked opponents. They have worked to become better after each game.
"I think the one thing that we've tried to stay true to is every game, every half, win or lose, we are trying to get better, improve and dissect it," Nahas said.
After losing to Duke twice before the postseason, UNC upset the No. 1 Blue Devils, 2-1, to reach the championship again with the help of young players like first-year defender Trinity Armstrong. The defender had a goal line save and scored the go-ahead goal.
Even in a time of transition for the program, the Tar Heels still found themselves in the ACC championship game once again, facing its fellow Goliath.
North Carolina isn't the same team that took on the Seminoles earlier this season in late October.
Against the then-No. 17 FSU squad, the Tar Heels sputtered. With the score tied 2-2 at the end of the first half, the Seminoles held UNC scoreless while notching two more of their own en route to a 4-2 win.
"In that first game, I didn't feel like we were back in the game," Nahas said. "We found a way to score two goals, but I never really felt like we were on the edge of winning that game. This was totally different."
The ACC championship game couldn't have been more different.
To get the day's news and headlines in your inbox each morning, sign up for our email newsletters.
The Tar Heels attacked from the opening whistle, outshooting the Seminoles 7-4 in the first half. They looked like the team representative of the historic program they play for.
But Florida State's firepower and experience made the difference.
The Seminoles' starting lineup featured two transfers and seven returners of its national championship team, one of whom — Ran Iwai — has been a member of each of FSU's five-peat ACC title teams. Nine members on the starting squad possess collegiate experience. Florida State also returned its 2023 leading scorer, Jordynn Dudley. This year, she's Florida State's second leading scorer. FSU's current leading scorer, Taylor Huff, made the starting lineup in all 23 games last season. On Sunday, Huff connected on a penalty kick to tie it, 2-2. She won MVP.
UNC's starters contain five returners and two transfers. Only one returning player logged double-digit starts last season. North Carolina's top scorer, Kate Faasse, didn't start a single game last year.
After the game, Nahas gathered his team in a circle while Florida State celebrated on the other side of the field. He consoled crying players. Eventually, they moved over to watch the Seminoles award ceremony.
"This loss hurts a lot more because the performance from this team was remarkable," Nahas said.
From new coaches to a completely different team, Nahas wanted the trophy for his team because of how they have handled it all. He is proud of the heights they have reached and the excellence he saw in the championship. He's ready for what's to come. UNC's future, despite initial uncertainty, is bright.
"I think this tournament is where I saw the biggest growth in our team and that was something that I am excited about," Nahas said. "And it wasn't just an individual. There [were] so many really good performances, and the belief is there."
@_emmahmoon
@dthsports | sports@dailytarheel.com