The Daily Tar Heel
Printing news. Raising hell. Since 1893.
Thursday, April 17, 2025 Newsletters Latest print issue

We keep you informed.

Help us keep going. Donate Today.
The Daily Tar Heel

'Pulse of the economy': How economic changes affect local second-hand shopping

city-economic-recession-secondhand-shopping.png
Texture courtesy of Adobe Stock.

Local musician Joyce Preslar has been thrifting in Orange County since 1978 and began working at Chatham PTA Thrift Shop in 1982.

She said she always goes to thrift stores before visiting retail stores because they are more affordable and are more likely to have what she is looking for.

Cathy Meerbergen, a project manager who has been shopping second-hand in the area for 14 years, said her favorite find is a $20 leather tote bag with a laptop sleeve that she consistently wears to work. 

Both Preslar and Meerbergen have noticed an increase in costs at their local thrift shops. This is due to store prices fluctuating with the economy, Keith Stinson, board president of Chatham PTA Thrift Shop, said. Last week, J.P. Morgan Research team announced a 40 percent probability of a global recession. The recession will likely impact a variety of industries, including the second-hand shopping market.

“[The thrift shop] is the pulse of the economy,” Stinson said

When the economy is bad, he said the thrift shop receives less donations because people are less willing to give up their belongings. The thrift shop also has higher sales because more people shop second-hand as a more affordable option, he said

Annie Williams, a clinical assistant professor of marketing at Kenan-Flagler Business School, said a looming recession will decrease consumer confidence, which will cause supply to decrease and demand to increase. She said this will create an imbalance in the market that will prompt thrift shops to increase prices.

“It’s more expensive to buy clothes now than it was years ago, so this could be a factor for more and more people to thrift,” King said

Preslar said that in her time shopping second-hand, she has witnessed different people come into and benefit from thrift shops. She said vulnerable community members use clothing vouchers at the thrift shop to buy affordable clothes for themselves and their children. 

Second-hand shopping has become a trend over the past couple of years, Williams said. She said this threatens the equity and accessibility of thrifting and prices out people who rely on second-hand shopping out of necessity. 

“I think [people who need to rely on thrift stores] are struggling, and if we layer an economic recession it’s only going to get worse,” Williams said.

Ed King, a local cartoonist, bought a $6 designer coat at a Carrboro thrift shop last week. Afterward, he found that it was listed online for $1,500 on a retail site. King said shopping second-hand is not only cheaper, but it is also an interesting experience.  

“Another important aspect too is that you’re supporting a good cause, like Habitat for Humanity, CommunityWorx and Chatham PTA,” Meerbergen said

Meerbergen said she enjoys seeing new and young customers at the thrift shop. Thrifting not only provides more original clothing, she said, but also preserves the environment by discouraging fast fashion practices. 

“When you think about thrift shops, it’s recycling something that’s still in good quality to allow someone else the opportunity to continue taking advantage of that product at a reasonable price, and that income we make is going back to a good cause,” Stinson said.

@kristinkharrat

@DTHCityState | city@dailytarheel.com

To get the day's news and headlines in your inbox each morning, sign up for our email newsletters.